Listful

We found ATM’s Schoolboy Crew to be the kind of tee you reach for on repeat—soft slub cotton that gets even comfier with wear and a classic crewneck that layers under blazers or cardigans.

Sep, 2025

Jo-Lynne Shane

The fabric and construction are excellent, and I've loved some ATM tees in the past.

Apr, 2025

Reddit

ATM - Anthony Thomas Melillo. I have a couple and they have become my most worn casual shirts.

Mar, 2025

The Cool Hour

Craftsmanship: 9/10. Crafted from soft, slubbed Peruvian cotton jersey, the tee exhibits a luxe finish. Minimalist design elements, such as clean cuts and an elegant drape, affirm its quality, making it a superior choice for casual wear.

Jan, 2025

Nordstrom

The slightly boxy, shrunken fit distinguishes the label's iconic crewneck T-shirt—made from supersoft slubbed jersey—that feels like an old favorite from the very first wear.

Jan, 2025

The Modest Man

Based on ATM's brand promise to provide leveled-up basics, I'd say they definitely hit the mark. They have a great foundation if the slub cotton shirt is the tentpole design. It's soft, well-built, beautifully dyed, and classic enough to be worn with anything, yet distinct enough to offer something more than the average essentials brand does with their shirts.

Nov, 2023

The Modest Man

Overall, ATM is worth the price, given it meets its brand promises for elevated and luxurious basics that are eco-conscious, well-built, and adaptable.

Nov, 2023

The Cool Hour

At $90, the price reflects the quality and unique design. While it may seem steep, its versatile appeal and luxurious material justify the investment for a staple wardrobe piece.

Jan, 2025

Listful

Care is less convenient—hand washing is recommended—and the $45 price is above mass‑market basics.

Sep, 2025

Jo-Lynne Shane

I love the cut/fit on you and I think it would be exactly what I'm looking for…except that it is nearly see-through. Ugh.

Apr, 2025